Is HI New York City Hostel worth it? Honest pros and cons

Yes — HI New York City Hostel is a practical, budget-friendly option if you want a social, centrally located hostel on the Upper West Side close to Central Park and Columbia University. It’s best for travelers comfortable with dormitory-style shared rooms and basic hostel facilities; families and private-room guests can find suitable options too.
In this guide
Location & neighborhood
HI New York City Hostel sits at 891 Amsterdam Avenue (103rd Street) on Manhattan’s Upper West Side. The building is a short walk to Central Park (about 8–10 minutes) and within easy walking distance of Columbia University and Riverside Park.
The hostel is closest to the 103rd Street 1-train station (a 2–3 minute walk). Midtown (Times Square) and many museums are reachable by subway in around 15–30 minutes depending on your destination.
If you need quick convenience shopping, a 7-Eleven is listed as a 5-minute walk from the property.
- Address: 891 Amsterdam Avenue, New York, NY 10025
- Nearest subway: 103rd Street (1 line) ~2–3 minute walk
- Walk to Central Park: ~8–10 minutes
| Nearby spot | Approximate time |
|---|---|
| Central Park | 8–10 min walk |
| Columbia University | About 13 min walk |
| Times Square (by subway) | 15–20 min |

Rooms and sleeping options
HI New York City Hostel offers a range of shared dormitory beds and private/family rooms. Dorms are available in multiple configurations including All-Gender, Women’s and Men’s rooms and various capacities (for example Bed in All-Gender 4-Bed Dormitory Room and Bed in All-Gender 12-Bed Dormitory Room).
Some private and family rooms are listed as having en-suite bathrooms on the hostel’s site. Room types are intended to suit solo travelers, groups and families, but expect hostel-style shared facilities in many room categories.
- Dorm options include: Bed in All-Gender 4-Bed Dormitory Room; Bed in Women’s 6-Bed Dormitory Room; Bed in All-Gender 10-Bed Dormitory Room; and more.
- Private/family rooms available; some list en-suite bathrooms (check the specific room description when booking).
- Children over age 2 must have their own bunk in dorm rooms; children under 7 cannot sleep in top bunks.
| Example room names | Bed type |
|---|---|
| Bed in All-Gender 4-Bed Dormitory Room | Twin bunk/dorm bed |
| Bed in All-Gender 12-Bed Dormitory Room | Twin bunk/dorm bed |
| Bed in Women's 6-Bed Dormitory Room | Twin bunk/dorm bed |

Facilities & common areas
The hostel offers free Wi‑Fi throughout, a large self-catering community kitchen, a games/TV room with a pool (billiards) table, a movie lounge, and a sizable outdoor patio/garden. The on-site Big Apple Café is open daily from 6:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m., and there is an on-site bar that serves beer, wine and non-alcoholic drinks until midnight.
There is no swimming pool, spa, or dedicated fitness center; instead the hostel provides recreational options such as the billiards table and an exercise mirror in common areas.
- Free Wi‑Fi in rooms and common areas
- Self-catering community kitchen and café (Big Apple Café, 6am–11pm)
- Games/TV room, movie lounge, billiards table
- Outdoor patio/garden (Green Space) for relaxing and events
- On-site bar (closes at midnight)
| Facility | Notes |
|---|---|
| Community kitchen | Large self-catering kitchen available to guests |
| Big Apple Café | Open daily 6:00 a.m.–11:00 p.m.; snack/café service |
| Outdoor patio / Green Space | Guest access; also rentable for events |

Events, meeting spaces and weddings
HI New York City Hostel operates multiple rentable event spaces on-site: The Ballroom (1,900 sq ft), The SoHo Room (1,450 sq ft), The Green Space (5,600 sq ft outdoor), and a Penthouse option for smaller gatherings. These spaces are available for conferences, private parties and wedding receptions, with tables and chairs included for the larger indoor rooms.
Rental terms include a $300 security deposit and minimum rental periods (4-hour minimums are noted for several spaces). Indoor rentals must end by 11:00 p.m.; Green Space rentals end by 10:00 p.m. The venues do not provide alcohol and do not allow outside alcohol to be brought in.
- The Ballroom: 1,900 sq ft, up to 163 standing (110 seated); $350/hour listed on the venue page
- The SoHo Room: 1,450 sq ft, up to 100 capacity; podium included; $300/hour listed
- The Green Space: 5,600 sq ft outdoor terrace, up to 150 guests; $450/hour listed; rental hours 8am–10pm
- Penthouse: smaller indoor option seating up to 36 (round tables) or 40 standing
| Space | Capacity (seated/standing) |
|---|---|
| The Ballroom | 110 seated / 163 standing |
| The SoHo Room | Up to 100 |
| The Green Space | Up to 150 (outdoor) |
Policies & practicalities
Check-in officially begins at 4:00 PM and check-out is at 11:00 AM. Some third-party booking sites list late arrivals accepted until 2:00 AM subject to availability. The main guest on any booking must be at least 18 years old, and anyone under 18 must be accompanied by a parent or legal guardian.
The hostel enforces a residency policy: rooms are generally available only to guests who live outside New York City (third-party sites cite an approximate 45–50 mile exclusion radius). There is a maximum stay limit of 21 days per calendar year.
- Official check-in: 4:00 PM; check-out: 11:00 AM
- Minimum main-guest age: 18; minors must be with a guardian
- Maximum stay: 21 days per calendar year
- No on-site parking; street parking is limited and regulated
- Cash is not accepted — major credit/debit cards only
| Policy | Detail |
|---|---|
| Payment | Credit/debit cards accepted; cash not accepted |
| Pets | Pets not allowed; service animals welcome |
| Group bookings | Online bookings limited to 9 guests; 10+ must contact hostel |
Who should stay here — pros and cons
HI New York City Hostel is a good fit for budget-minded travelers who want a social hostel environment with organized activities, easy access to public transit, and a central Uptown location near Central Park. Dorms and shared facilities make it easy to meet other travelers; private rooms are available for those wanting more privacy.
It’s less suitable if you need quiet luxury, a full-service hotel experience, on-site parking, or a gym and spa. The residency restriction also rules out local New York City residents, and some guests may prefer smaller boutique hotels for a quieter stay.
- Pros: central Upper West Side location; close to Central Park and subway; free Wi‑Fi; large kitchen and social spaces; on-site café and bar; multiple event spaces.
- Cons: shared-bath dorms common; no pool or fitness center; no on-site parking; residency restriction for NYC locals; cashless policy may be inconvenient for some guests.
| Best for | Not ideal for |
|---|---|
| Backpackers, solo travelers, groups, budget families | Car travelers needing parking, guests seeking a hotel gym or spa |
| People who want social events and activities | Travelers wanting quiet, luxury or full hotel services |
| Event planners needing a central Manhattan venue | Local NYC residents (generally ineligible to book) |

