Best rooms at HI New York City Hostel, ranked

Top picks are the lower-occupancy dorms for comfort and quiet: Bed in All-Gender 4-Bed Dormitory Room and Bed in Women's 4-Bed Dormitory Room. For budget travelers who want the cheapest option, larger mixed dorms (for example, Bed in All-Gender 12-Bed Dormitory Room) give the lowest per-bed cost but less privacy.
In this guide
Ranked quick list — best rooms at a glance
This ranking focuses on the hostel’s shared dormitory beds (the property lists 16 dorm-style bed types). I rank by typical traveler priorities: privacy, noise, space and suitability for families or groups.
I list the top six dorm-bed options that travelers most often choose, noting trade-offs between privacy and price. The property also offers private and family rooms, but their specific room-type names were not provided in the available facts.
- 1 — Bed in All-Gender 4-Bed Dormitory Room (best balance of price + privacy).
- 2 — Bed in Women's 4-Bed Dormitory Room (good privacy for solo women travelers).
- 3 — Bed in Men's 4-Bed Dormitory Room (quiet option for men-only groups).
- 4 — Bed in All-Gender 6-Bed Dormitory Room (small mixed dorm for groups).
- 5 — Bed in All-Gender 10-Bed Dormitory Room (mid-size, common compromise).
- 6 — Bed in All-Gender 12-Bed Dormitory Room (best for the lowest-cost per bed).
| Rank | Room name | Why choose it |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Bed in All-Gender 4-Bed Dormitory Room | Best balance of privacy and budget in a shared room |
| 2 | Bed in Women's 4-Bed Dormitory Room | Smaller room limited to women, usually quieter and more private |
| 3 | Bed in Men's 4-Bed Dormitory Room | Small men-only dorm for groups or solo men seeking privacy |
| 4 | Bed in All-Gender 6-Bed Dormitory Room | Slightly larger mixed dorm for small groups |
| 5 | Bed in All-Gender 10-Bed Dormitory Room | Mid-size mixed dorm — compromise between price and noise |
| 6 | Bed in All-Gender 12-Bed Dormitory Room | Largest common dorm listed here — best for strict budget travelers |
Best for solo travelers who want a quieter stay
Choose one of the 4-bed dormitory options. The smaller head-count reduces overall noise and foot traffic compared with 10-, 12- or 14-bed dorms.
Both mixed and single-gender 4-bed options are available. If you prefer same-gender roommates, the property lists Bed in Women's 4-Bed Dormitory Room and Bed in Men's 4-Bed Dormitory Room as specific options.
- Bed in All-Gender 4-Bed Dormitory Room — good balance of meeting other travelers while keeping the room manageable.
- Bed in Women's 4-Bed Dormitory Room — better privacy and comfort for solo women.
- Bed in Men's 4-Bed Dormitory Room — same benefit for men seeking a men-only dorm.
| Feature | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Fewer bunks | Less late-night disturbance and fewer shared lockers/bathroom queue issues |
| Gender-specific options | Can feel safer or more comfortable for some travelers |
| Easier to coordinate with friends | Small rooms are easier to reserve for a full-group booking (subject to the hostel’s booking limits) |

Best for groups and families
If you’re traveling with a family or a small group, pick a smaller private room or reserve multiple bunks in the same dorm. The hostel lists family rooms and private rooms in addition to the dorm beds, though the specific private-room names were not provided in the facts.
For groups wanting to stay together within dorms, the 6-bed or 8-bed dorms are useful: they offer a middle ground between privacy and the ability to keep your party in one room.
- Bed in All-Gender 6-Bed Dormitory Room — good choice for small groups who want a single room.
- Bed in All-Gender 8-Bed Dormitory Room — slightly larger but still easier to keep the group together than 10+ bed dorms.
- If you need a true family layout, ask the hostel about its private family rooms when booking (availability and exact names were not listed in the provided facts).
| Option | When to pick it |
|---|---|
| Bed in All-Gender 6-Bed Dormitory Room | Small groups or families travelling together who want shared space |
| Bed in All-Gender 8-Bed Dormitory Room | Groups of 4–8 who want to stay in one room without booking multiple private rooms |
| Private or family rooms (ask at booking) | Families who prefer a private bedroom rather than bunks |

Best for the lowest price
Larger dorms typically offer the cheapest per-bed rate. The property lists several large mixed and single-gender dorms, such as Bed in All-Gender 12-Bed Dormitory Room and Bed in Men's 14-Bed Dormitory Room.
Expect more noise, more people using shared bathrooms, and less personal space in the biggest dorms — these are best if you prioritize saving money over privacy.
- Bed in All-Gender 12-Bed Dormitory Room — large mixed dorm for the most budget-conscious travelers.
- Bed in Men´s 14-Bed Dormitory Room — large single-gender dorm option for men.
- Bed in All-Gender 10-Bed Dormitory Room — another large but slightly smaller option than 12- or 14-bed rooms.
| Dorm size | Typical trade-off |
|---|---|
| 10–12 beds | Lower price per bed, moderate crowding |
| 14 beds | Lowest per-bed price, higher crowding and noise |
| 4–6 beds | Higher per-bed price, more privacy and quiet |
What to expect from room facilities and common areas
Rooms are dorm-style beds or private/family rooms; free Wi‑Fi is available throughout the property, including in dorm and private rooms. Some private/family rooms and dorms may have en-suite bathrooms, but specific en-suite assignments were not listed in the provided facts.
Shared facilities that matter to dorm guests include a large self-catering community kitchen, the Big Apple Café (open daily 6 a.m.–11 p.m.), a games/TV room with a pool table, a movie lounge and a large outdoor patio/garden.
- Free Wi‑Fi in rooms and common areas.
- Self-catering kitchen and stainless cooking area for guests.
- Big Apple Café on-site (6 a.m.–11 p.m.) and a bar that closes at midnight.
- Outdoor patio/garden for relaxing or social events.
| Facility | Availability / note |
|---|---|
| Big Apple Café | Open daily 6 a.m. to 11 p.m.; touchscreen ordering kiosks available |
| Bar | Serves beer, wine and non-alcoholic drinks; closes at midnight |
| Kitchen and game rooms | Self-catering kitchen and games/TV room with pool table |

How to choose the right bed when you book
Decide what matters most: privacy (pick 4-bed dorms or a private/family room), same-gender roommates (choose one of the Women’s or Men’s dorms), or the lowest nightly cost (choose larger mixed dorms).
Remember the hostel has booking limits and policies that affect groups: online bookings are capped at 9 guests per reservation, the main guest must be at least 18, and the hostel enforces a local-residency restriction (rooms are generally not offered to New York City residents).
- If you need same-gender privacy: choose Bed in Women's X-Bed or Bed in Men's X-Bed options.
- If traveling as a family: inquire about private/family rooms (names and availability not provided in the facts).
- For group reservations of 10+: contact the hostel directly as online bookings are limited to 9 guests.
| Booking need | What to request |
|---|---|
| Same-gender roommates | Book a Women’s or Men’s dorm option |
| Maximum group size | Reserve up to 9 guests online, contact hostel for larger groups |
| Younger travelers or children | Main guest must be 18+; children under 18 must be with parent/guardian |

