
HI New York City Hostel
Best for budget travelers, groups and anyone who values social spaces and a large self-catering kitchen.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
HI New York City Hostel is a budget-oriented, community hostel in a historic Upper West Side building; read this if you want social dorms, a big common kitchen and event spaces. 1 Hotel Central Park is an eco-luxury, 5-star lifestyle hotel near Central Park; read this if you want upscale rooms, sustainability features and a Midtown location close to attractions.
Updated

Best for budget travelers, groups and anyone who values social spaces and a large self-catering kitchen.

Best for travelers who want upscale, design-forward rooms, sustainability-minded amenities and a Midtown location steps from Central Park.
When HI New York City Hostel wins: Choose HI if you need the cheapest beds or private rooms in a social setting, want event or group spaces, or plan to meet other travelers and use a self-catering kitchen.
When 1 Hotel Central Park wins: Choose 1 Hotel for high-end rooms, concierge services, an on-site cafe/bar with table service, eco-focused features and a location immediately adjacent to Central Park and Midtown attractions.
Bottom line: These are different products for different priorities — HI is about affordability, community and event spaces on the Upper West Side; 1 Hotel Central Park is a polished, eco-luxury Midtown alternative for travelers who want more service and design in their stay.
| Category | HI New York City Hostel | 1 Hotel Central Park |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Social, budget hostel in a historic building with shared facilities | Design-driven, eco-luxury 5-star hotel |
| Location | Upper West Side (891 Amsterdam Ave) — ~8–10 minute walk to Central Park | Midtown near Central Park (1414 Avenue of the Americas) — steps from Central Park |
| Size | Hostel with many dorm beds and a selection of private/family rooms; multiple event spaces | 229 guestrooms (supplier listing) |
| Ages / audience | All ages welcome; many guests are 18–30; minors must be with a guardian | All ages welcome (not adults-only); typical luxury hotel mix |
| Pools | No on-site swimming pool | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Big Apple Café (snack/cafe) plus an on-site bar (closes at midnight) | Jams Cafe (restaurant) and a bar/lounge plus a coffee shop/cafe |
| Spa & fitness | No spa or dedicated fitness center; small exercise mirror in common area | Health/beauty spa listed as nearby and 24-hour fitness facilities listed in supplier amenities |
| Known for | Large outdoor patio/garden, social events, and rentable event spaces (Ballroom, Green Space) | Eco-conscious operations, locally-sourced food, living plant wall and concierge services |
| Rooms | Dormitory beds (mixed and gendered, multiple capacities) plus private/family rooms; many shared bathrooms | Multiple room types including Alcove Queen, Alcove King, Park View 1 King Bed, Park Suite, City Suite (supplier list) |
| Accessibility & family features | Family rooms available; children allowed with guardian; no pets | Wheelchair accessible features listed; children’s toys mentioned and pets can be arranged by contacting property |
HI New York City Hostel sits on Amsterdam Avenue at West 103rd Street in the Upper West Side, within walking distance of Central Park and Columbia University.
Choose HI for a quieter Upper West Side base with good subway links and a short walk to the park.
1 Hotel Central Park is located on Avenue of the Americas in Midtown, immediately close to Central Park and several museums and Midtown attractions.
Choose 1 Hotel for maximum proximity to Central Park and Midtown sightseeing.
HI offers shared dormitory beds in multiple gender configurations plus private and family rooms; some private rooms have en-suite baths.
Pick HI if you prioritize low cost, flexibility and meeting other travelers.
1 Hotel Central Park offers 229 guestrooms across a range of room types from Alcove Queen to Park Suite, with in-room fridges and LCD TVs noted in the supplier listing.
Pick 1 Hotel for upscale, fully serviced rooms with design and eco-focused amenities.
HI’s food options are focused on a self-service cafe and a hostel bar.
HI is practical for budget meals and cooking for yourself.
1 Hotel Central Park lists an on-site restaurant (Jams Cafe), a bar/lounge and a coffee shop/cafe on the supplier listing.
Choose 1 Hotel if you want hotel dining, table service and curated sustainable menus.
HI's signature shared spaces are its large outdoor patio/garden and common rooms rather than a pool.
HI is about communal outdoor and indoor social spaces, not resort-style water features.
1 Hotel Central Park highlights eco-minded design features such as a living plant wall and sustainability practices.
1 Hotel focuses on sustainable design and in-hotel lifestyle features rather than party-style communal spaces.
HI runs nightly social events but enforces quiet hours; nightlife is mostly social within the hostel and nearby bars.
HI is best if you want hostel-hosted events and an easy social scene without late-night hotel services.
1 Hotel Central Park offers full-service concierge, express check-in/out and 24-hour business/fitness facilities per supplier listing.
1 Hotel suits travelers who want full-service amenities, a 24-hour fitness option and concierge support.

HI New York City Hostel — lowest-cost dorm beds, self-catering kitchen and social common areas.

HI New York City Hostel — multiple rentable event spaces including The Ballroom, SoHo Room and Green Space.

1 Hotel Central Park — 5-star rooms, concierge services and immediate proximity to Central Park and Midtown sights.

1 Hotel Central Park — supplier-listed recycling, no single-use plastics, living plant wall and locally-sourced food options.
1 Hotel Central Park is immediately adjacent to Central Park; HI New York City Hostel is about an 8–10 minute walk to the park.
Yes — HI offers both private and family rooms in addition to numerous dormitory options; some private rooms have en-suite bathrooms.
No. 1 Hotel Central Park is not adults-only; it accommodates guests of all ages per the supplier listing.
Yes — HI New York City Hostel offers several event spaces (Ballroom, SoHo Room, Green Space and Penthouse) that can be rented for events, with specific hours and security deposit requirements.
Explore how HI New York City Hostel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·