
HI New York City Hostel
Best for budget-minded travelers, solo backpackers, and families who want social common areas and event/meeting spaces.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
HI New York City Hostel is a social, budget-conscious hostel in a historic Upper West Side building that suits young travelers, families, and groups. The Surrey A Corinthia Hotel is a refined Upper East Side 5-star hotel appealing to travelers who want luxury rooms, a full-service spa, and a Central Park–adjacent location.
Updated · about 2.2 km apart

Best for budget-minded travelers, solo backpackers, and families who want social common areas and event/meeting spaces.

Best for travelers seeking upscale rooms, concierge service, and a spa-focused, Central Park–adjacent Upper East Side stay.
When HI New York City Hostel wins: choose HI NYC if you want low-cost beds or private rooms, a social atmosphere with regular activities, large communal kitchen and garden, or if you need flexible event space for group bookings.
When The Surrey A Corinthia Hotel wins: choose The Surrey for refined, quiet accommodations near Central Park and Museum Mile, full-service spa access, concierge and valet services, and higher-end dining.
Bottom line: these two properties serve different needs — HI New York City Hostel is about community, cost savings, and events in a landmark building; The Surrey A Corinthia Hotel is an Upper East Side luxury hotel for travelers prioritizing comfort, service, and a spa/dining experience.
| Category | HI New York City Hostel | The Surrey A Corinthia Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Social, hostel-style; shared common spaces and activities. | Refined luxury hotel with personalized service. |
| Location | Upper West Side, near Central Park (about 0.4 mi walk). | Upper East Side, a 5-minute walk from Central Park and minutes from the Met (20 East 76th St). |
| Size | Historic hostel building with many dormitory beds and private/family rooms (multiple room types listed). | 100 guestrooms (supplier listing). |
| Typical guest ages / policy | All ages welcome; main booker must be 18+; family-friendly. | All ages welcome; adults-only: false. |
| Pools | No swimming pool on site (hostel lists patio/garden instead). | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Big Apple Café (6:00 AM–11:00 PM) and an on-site bar serving beer, wine, non-alcoholic drinks. | Casa Tua (Italian cuisine), 1 bar/lounge, 24-hour room service, cooked-to-order breakfast available (surcharge). |
| Spa / wellness | No on-site spa; communal exercise mirror and games/TV room instead. | Full-service spa with treatments; 24-hour fitness facilities and fitness classes on site. |
| Known for | Large communal spaces, hostel activities, and rentable event venues (Ballroom, Green Space, Penthouse). | Central Park proximity, luxury bedding (Frette sheets), concierge and valet services. |
| Accessibility & family features | Family rooms available; children policies defined (minors rules), wheelchair accessibility noted. | Wheelchair-accessible paths and registration desk; assistive listening and Braille signage available. |
| Parking / transport notes | No on-site parking; close to 103rd St subway (1 line) and other transit. | Off-street parking and valet available (surcharge); limo/town car service offered. |
HI New York City Hostel sits at 891 Amsterdam Avenue near West 103rd Street, a short walk to Central Park and local subway lines.
Choose HI NYC if you want Upper West Side energy, close subway access, and quick pedestrian access to Central Park.
The Surrey A Corinthia Hotel is at 20 East 76th Street on the Upper East Side, steps from Madison Avenue and a short walk to the Met.
Choose The Surrey for a quieter, museum-and-Madison-Avenue–focused Uptown location with short walks to Central Park.
HI New York City Hostel offers many shared dormitory beds plus private and family rooms in a landmark building.
Pick HI NYC for affordable dorm beds or basic private rooms when price and social space matter more than luxury finishes.
The Surrey A Corinthia Hotel provides 100 guestrooms with upscale bedding and a range of suites and accessible room types.
Pick The Surrey for spacious, well-appointed rooms and a choice of suites with luxury amenities and accessible options.
HI New York City Hostel keeps dining simple with a café and a casual on-site bar.
HI NYC is best if you want low-cost, flexible food options and a communal kitchen rather than formal dining.
The Surrey features Italian dining (Casa Tua), a bar/lounge, and 24-hour room service.
Choose The Surrey for sit-down dining, 24-hour room service, and concierge-assisted reservations.
HI New York City Hostel highlights a large outdoor patio/garden and multiple rentable event spaces rather than a pool or spa.
HI NYC's signature features are communal outdoor space and flexible event venues rather than wellness facilities.
The Surrey’s signature amenities include a full-service spa and 24-hour fitness facilities.
Pick The Surrey if an on-site spa and fitness options matter to your stay.
HI New York City Hostel programs regular free activities and maintains communal entertainment spaces.
If social programming and evening events are part of your trip, the hostel keeps a steady calendar of activities.
The Surrey offers a quieter, service-oriented nightlife experience focused on in-house dining, bars, and the surrounding Upper East Side.
Choose The Surrey for calm evenings, upscale dining, and concierge-arranged nights out.

Dorm beds, low-cost private rooms, self-catering kitchen and social common areas.

Large rentable event spaces (Green Space, Ballroom, SoHo Room) and family rooms available.

Refined rooms, concierge service, full-service spa and valet/covered parking.

A 5-minute walk to Central Park and a short walk to the Metropolitan Museum of Art.
The Surrey A Corinthia Hotel is the closer option — it's about a 5-minute walk to the Met. HI New York City Hostel is farther from the Met and is better placed for Upper West Side access.
Families can stay at both, but HI New York City Hostel explicitly offers family rooms and family-friendly policies. The Surrey is not adults-only and allows children, but check the hotel's policies and room types for family suitability.
HI New York City Hostel does not have a swimming pool. The supplier listing for The Surrey does not publish a pool; the Surrey's notable wellness offering is a full-service spa and fitness facilities.
HI New York City Hostel — it runs regular social activities, has shared dorms and communal kitchens, and features bar and lounge spaces geared toward meeting other travelers.
Explore how HI New York City Hostel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·