
HI New York City Hostel
Best for social, budget, and family travelers who want to meet other guests, use a communal kitchen, and stay near Central Park.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
HI New York City Hostel is a budget-friendly, all-ages hostel in a Victorian-era building on the Upper West Side that suits social, budget, and family travelers who want shared common spaces and a self-catering kitchen. The New York EDITION is a 5-star luxury lifestyle hotel by Madison Square Park aimed at design-conscious travelers seeking upscale rooms, on-site dining, and concierge services.
Updated · about 4.0 miles (6.4 km) apart

Best for social, budget, and family travelers who want to meet other guests, use a communal kitchen, and stay near Central Park.

Best for travelers who want a full-service, design-led luxury stay steps from Madison Square Park and the Flatiron/5th Avenue area.
When HI New York City Hostel wins: choose HI if you want the lowest nightly cost in Manhattan, dormitory-style or private rooms with shared facilities, a large outdoor patio/garden, frequent free activities, and event spaces for group bookings or affordable weddings.
When The New York EDITION wins: choose The New York EDITION if you want 5-star service, a higher level of in-room comfort (pillowtop beds, minibars, Smart TVs), on-site fine dining (The Clocktower), concierge services, spa treatments, and a central Flatiron/Madison Square Park address.
Bottom line: pick HI New York City Hostel for budget, social stays or group events and a neighborhood near Central Park; pick The New York EDITION for a full-service, design-oriented luxury experience in central Manhattan.
| Category | HI New York City Hostel | The New York EDITION |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Casual, social, budget hostel with shared common spaces and activities | Luxury lifestyle hotel with design focus and full services |
| Location | Upper West Side, near Central Park (about 0.4 mi to Central Park) | Madison Square Park / Flatiron district (steps from Madison Square Park) |
| Size | Historic Victorian building with many dormitory beds and private rooms (16 room types listed) | 271 air-conditioned rooms |
| Ages / audience | All ages welcome; most guests 18–30 but families and seniors can stay (main guest must be 18) | All ages welcome (not adults-only) |
| Pools | No swimming pool | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Big Apple Café (6:00 AM–11:00 PM) and an on-site bar (closes at midnight) | The Clocktower restaurant, 2 bars/lounges, 24-hour room service |
| Spa & wellness | No spa; common-area amenities include a pool (billiards) table and exercise mirror | Onsite massages and facials; spa services available |
| Known for | Large social spaces, self-catering kitchen, free activities, event and wedding venues | Design-forward luxury experience near Madison Square Park and Flatiron Building |
| Accessibility & family rules | Family-friendly; main guest must be 18; children over 2 need their own bunk in dorms | Wheelchair accessibility features listed (various mobility-accessible room types) |
| Meeting & events | Multiple event spaces (The Ballroom, SoHo Room, Green Space, Penthouse) with rental rates and capacity details | Conference space ~2100 sq ft and 5 meeting rooms |
HI New York City Hostel sits on Amsterdam Avenue at West 103rd Street near Central Park and several subway lines.
Takeaway: choose HI if you want an Upper West Side base near Central Park and easy subway access.
The New York EDITION is located at 5 Madison Avenue, steps from Madison Square Park and the Flatiron Building.
Takeaway: choose The New York EDITION for a central Flatiron/Madison Square Park location within walking distance of many downtown attractions.
HI New York City Hostel offers dormitory beds and private/family rooms in a landmark Victorian building.
Takeaway: HI is for travelers who accept shared rooms and lower-cost private rooms to stay centrally on a budget.
The New York EDITION offers 271 air-conditioned, design-conscious rooms with in-room comforts.
Takeaway: The EDITION provides full-service, upscale rooms for travelers seeking comfort and design.
HI New York City Hostel has an on-site café and a modest bar that suits casual, self-catered dining.
Takeaway: HI is oriented to informal, budget eating — cafe, communal kitchen and a small bar.
The New York EDITION has formal dining and multiple bars appropriate for upscale meals and drinks.
Takeaway: The EDITION offers full-service dining and bar options for guests who prefer hotel restaurants and room service.
HI New York City Hostel emphasizes common social spaces for meeting other travelers and group activities.
Takeaway: HI’s signature selling point is social common spaces and programming for budget travelers and groups.
The New York EDITION’s signature is its full-service hotel amenities, including spa treatments and concierge services.
Takeaway: The EDITION’s signature amenities cater to guests looking for service, comfort, and in-house wellness.
HI New York City Hostel provides social nightlife and light fitness-style facilities rather than formal wellness services.
Takeaway: HI is social but not a nightlife club or spa — it focuses on communal events and low-cost entertainment.
The New York EDITION offers late-night bars, on-site fitness facilities, and spa services for a hotel-style wellness balance.
Takeaway: The EDITION supports both evening socializing in bars and in-house wellness services for guests wanting hotel-level amenities.

HI New York City Hostel — dorms, daily activities, communal kitchen and large common areas make socializing easy.

The New York EDITION — 5-star rooms, concierge, spa treatments and on-site fine dining.

HI New York City Hostel — multiple rentable event spaces (Ballroom, SoHo Room, Green Space) with published capacities and hourly rates.

The New York EDITION — steps from Madison Square Park and close to 5th Avenue and Flatiron destinations.
HI New York City Hostel — it offers dormitory beds and low-cost private rooms plus a self-catering kitchen and free Wi‑Fi.
No — both properties welcome all ages; HI has specific rules for minors in dorms and the main guest must be at least 18.
HI New York City Hostel — it’s about a 8–10 minute walk (roughly 0.4 miles) to Central Park.
Yes — the listing mentions onsite massages and facials plus fitness facilities; specific pool presence is not published in the supplier listing.
Explore how HI New York City Hostel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·