
HI New York City Hostel
Best for budget-conscious travelers and groups who value social spaces, events, and a central Upper West Side base near Central Park.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
HI New York City Hostel is a budget-friendly, social hostel in a landmark Upper West Side building; this guide is for travelers who want communal, low-cost stays near Central Park. The Greenwich Hotel is a 5-star, celebrity-favored boutique in Tribeca; read on if you want private, service-led luxury in downtown Manhattan.
Updated · about 6.5 km apart

Best for budget-conscious travelers and groups who value social spaces, events, and a central Upper West Side base near Central Park.

Best for travelers seeking privacy, high-end service, a full-service spa and pools, and a quiet Tribeca location favored by celebrities.
When HI New York City Hostel wins: choose the hostel if you want to meet other travelers, use a large self-catering kitchen, join free activities, and stay cheaply within walking distance of Central Park and Columbia University.
When The Greenwich Hotel wins: pick The Greenwich Hotel for individually serviced luxury rooms and suites, extensive wellness and pool facilities, concierge service, and downtown Tribeca proximity to galleries and boutique shopping.
Bottom line: these properties offer very different Manhattan experiences — HI is communal and budget-focused on the Upper West Side, while The Greenwich Hotel is a private, full-service boutique luxury option in Tribeca. Pick based on whether you prioritize social, low-cost lodging or private, high-service accommodation.
| Category | HI New York City Hostel | The Greenwich Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Informal, social hostel in a landmark Victorian-era building | Quiet, high-end boutique hotel with bespoke service |
| Location (neighborhood) | Upper West Side (near Central Park) | Tribeca (downtown Manhattan) |
| Size | Large hostel with many dormitory and private room types | Not published |
| Ages / audience | All ages; most guests 18–30 but families and seniors welcome | All ages (not adults-only) |
| Pools | No swimming pool | Indoor and outdoor swimming pool listed |
| Restaurants & bars | Big Apple Café (6am–11pm) plus on-site bar serving beer & wine | Restaurants, poolside bar, coffee shop, bar, room service listed |
| Spa & wellness | No spa; common-area exercise mirror and yoga room | Spa, massage, fitness center and yoga room listed |
| Known for | Communal travel culture, events, large outdoor patio/Green Space | Tribeca boutique luxury and high service standards |
| Accessibility & family rules | Family-friendly with child rules for dorms; minimum main guest age 18 | Wheelchair accessible; minimum check-in age not published |
| Event spaces | Multiple rentable event spaces (Ballroom, SoHo Room, Green Space, Penthouse) | Event booking and concierge services listed |
HI New York City Hostel sits on Amsterdam Avenue near West 103rd Street, an easy walk to Central Park and Columbia University.
Choose HI for a lively Uptown base convenient for parks and university visits.
The Greenwich Hotel is located at 377 Greenwich Street in Tribeca, within walking distance of downtown attractions and subway stops.
Pick The Greenwich Hotel for a quieter, upscale downtown location with easy access to Tribeca and lower Manhattan.
HI New York City Hostel offers many dormitory configurations plus private and family rooms.
HI is for travelers willing to share rooms for lower rates and social opportunities.
The Greenwich Hotel lists several private room and suite types, from Superior King Room to various corner suites.
The Greenwich Hotel focuses on private, higher-comfort rooms and multiple suite configurations.
HI New York City Hostel keeps dining simple with a self-service café and a bar.
HI is practical for budget travelers who want a kitchen and late café service.
The Greenwich Hotel lists restaurants, a poolside bar, a coffee shop and room service.
The Greenwich Hotel provides full-service dining choices and concierge-led reservations.
HI New York City Hostel features a large outdoor patio and garden but does not have a swimming pool.
If an outdoor garden for socializing and events matters, HI delivers; it does not offer pool facilities.
The Greenwich Hotel's supplier listing includes both indoor and outdoor swimming pool facilities.
The Greenwich Hotel caters to guests who want dedicated pool facilities as part of a luxury stay.
HI New York City Hostel runs free social activities and offers basic fitness-style amenities in common areas.
HI is strongest for social programming and low-cost, on-site activities rather than formal wellness services.
The Greenwich Hotel lists a full set of wellness amenities and concierge-driven services.
The Greenwich Hotel is the choice for travelers wanting professional spa treatments and a concierge for planning.

Large shared dorms, daily social events and communal spaces (games room, movie lounge, Green Space).

Private suites, 5-star service, spa, indoor and outdoor pools, and concierge assistance.

Multiple rentable event spaces (Ballroom, SoHo Room, Green Space, Penthouse) with transparent rental terms.

Spa services and both indoor and outdoor pool facilities listed by the supplier.
HI New York City Hostel — it's about a 8–10 minute walk (roughly 0.4 miles) to Central Park; The Greenwich Hotel is in Tribeca, much farther downtown.
Yes. HI New York City Hostel is family-friendly with rules for children in dorms; The Greenwich Hotel is not adults-only and accommodates guests of varying ages.
The Greenwich Hotel — supplier listings include a spa plus indoor and outdoor pools; HI New York City Hostel does not have a pool or spa.
No. HI New York City Hostel offers a café and a self-catering kitchen but no all-inclusive meal plan; The Greenwich Hotel offers on-site dining and room service but supplier notes do not show any all-inclusive meal package.
Explore how HI New York City Hostel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·