
HI New York City Hostel
Best for budget-conscious travelers and groups who want social common spaces and event venues.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
HI New York City Hostel is an affordable, social hostel in a historic Upper West Side building good for budget travelers, groups, and families who want shared spaces and easy access to Central Park. The Peninsula New York is a classic Fifth Avenue luxury hotel for travelers who want full-service rooms, a spa, and a Midtown location near MoMA and Rockefeller Center.
Updated · about 3.9 km apart

Best for budget-conscious travelers and groups who want social common spaces and event venues.

Best for travelers seeking full-service luxury, a spa, and a central Midtown location near major sights.
When HI New York City Hostel wins: if you want the lowest nightly cost, dorm-style social sleepovers, communal kitchens, group event spaces, or to meet other travelers, the hostel is the clearer choice.
When The Peninsula New York wins: if you prefer private rooms, premium bedding, an indoor pool and full-service spa, concierge and valet services, and walking distance to Fifth Avenue attractions, choose The Peninsula.
Bottom line: both are useful bases for sightseeing in Manhattan, but they serve very different budgets and trip styles — HI NYC for social, economical stays; The Peninsula for classic luxury and full-service amenities.
| Category | HI New York City Hostel | The Peninsula New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Informal, social, budget-minded hostel with shared spaces and activities | Formal, classic Fifth Avenue luxury hotel with full-service facilities |
| Location | Upper West Side (Amsterdam Ave at W 103rd St), near Central Park and subway | Midtown Manhattan (700 Fifth Avenue at 55th Street), steps from 5th Avenue and MoMA |
| Size / rooms | Multiple dormitory configurations and private/family rooms (16 room types listed) | 219 guestrooms with many room and suite types |
| Ages / audience | All-ages hostel; most guests 18–30 but families and older travelers welcome | All-ages luxury hotel; family-friendly policies and kids welcome |
| Pools / signature amenity | No swimming pool on site; outdoor patio/garden instead | Indoor pool plus pool sun loungers and pool access (listed) |
| Restaurants & bars | Big Apple Café (snack/cafeteria style) and an on-site bar; self-catering kitchen | Clement Restaurant, 24-hour room service, and multiple bars/lounges (3 listed) |
| Spa & wellness | No full-service spa; games room and exercise mirror in common areas | Full-service spa, steam room/sauna, 24-hour health club |
| Event spaces | Multiple event venues on site (Ballroom, SoHo Room, Green Space, Penthouse) for weddings and conferences | Meeting rooms available (5 meeting rooms listed) and banquet facilities |
| Accessibility & family rules | Family rooms available; children allowed with guardian; minimum main guest age 18; residency restrictions apply (non-NYC guests only) | Family-friendly with child policies; standard luxury-hotel check-in rules (min age for primary cardholder 21 listed in supplier policies) |
| Wi‑Fi & connectivity | Free Wi‑Fi throughout property, common areas and dorms | |
HI New York City Hostel sits on Amsterdam Avenue at W 103rd Street, a short walk to Central Park and nearby subway lines.
Choose the hostel if you want a quieter Upper West Side base near Central Park and easy subway access.
The Peninsula New York is on Fifth Avenue at 55th Street, in Midtown within walking distance of MoMA and Rockefeller Center.
Pick The Peninsula for prime Midtown access to museums, shopping, and tourist sights.
HI New York City Hostel offers dormitory beds and private/family rooms in a historic building.
The hostel’s dorms are for budget travelers or groups; private rooms are basic compared with a luxury hotel room.
The Peninsula New York has 219 guestrooms ranging from Superior Rooms to multiple suite levels.
The Peninsula offers serviced, private rooms and suites with luxury bedding and in-room amenities.
HI New York City Hostel provides on-site casual options and a communal kitchen.
Expect low-cost, casual dining and the flexibility of a shared kitchen at the hostel.
The Peninsula New York has a signature restaurant and multiple bars with room service.
The Peninsula provides full-service dining, multiple bars, and in-room dining for a more formal experience.
HI New York City Hostel focuses on communal indoor/outdoor social spaces rather than aquatic facilities.
Choose the hostel for outdoor social space and event venues rather than pool or spa facilities.
The Peninsula offers traditional luxury amenities including an indoor pool and spa services.
If an indoor pool and full-service spa are important, The Peninsula clearly provides those amenities.
HI New York City Hostel runs free guest activities and has casual, social nightlife on-site.
The hostel is geared to social travelers who want programming and on-site events rather than luxury wellness services.
The Peninsula provides staffed wellness facilities and a calmer, upscale evening experience.
The Peninsula is a better fit for travelers prioritizing spa and fitness amenities and a quieter luxury atmosphere.

Dorm beds, shared kitchens, and low-cost social spaces make HI the clear budget pick.

HI offers family rooms plus large indoor and outdoor event spaces for group gatherings and small weddings.

The Peninsula’s Fifth Avenue address puts you steps from MoMA, high-end shopping, and Midtown attractions.

Indoor pool, full-service spa, 24-hour health club and concierge services make The Peninsula a full-service luxury choice.
HI New York City Hostel is closer to Central Park (about an 8–10 minute walk); The Peninsula is a longer walk south into Midtown.
No. HI New York City Hostel does not have a swimming pool; The Peninsula has an indoor pool.
Yes. Both properties welcome families, but HI has family rooms and specific dorm rules for children while The Peninsula offers family-friendly luxury rooms and suites.
Neither property is sold as all-inclusive. HI has a café and self-catering kitchen; The Peninsula offers paid cooked-to-order breakfasts and full dining for a surcharge.
Explore how HI New York City Hostel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·