
HI New York City Hostel
Best for sociable, low-cost stays, group bookings, and travelers who value shared spaces and on-site events.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
HI New York City Hostel is a budget-focused, social hostel in a Victorian landmark on the Upper West Side; read this if you want cheap, sociable dorms or event spaces near Central Park. Four Seasons Hotel New York is a renowned Midtown luxury high-rise; read this if you want upscale service, individually decorated rooms, and a central Midtown address near Fifth Avenue and Central Park.
Updated · about 4.2 km apart

Best for sociable, low-cost stays, group bookings, and travelers who value shared spaces and on-site events.

Best for travelers seeking Midtown luxury, individually decorated guestrooms, and extensive meeting/event facilities with high-end service.
When HI New York City Hostel wins: choose HI if you want the cheapest base for exploring Manhattan, easy access to Central Park, dorms or private rooms, and lots of chances to meet other travelers or host informal events.
When Four Seasons Hotel New York wins: choose Four Seasons for high-end rooms with premium bedding and deep soaking tubs, a central Midtown address steps from Fifth Avenue and Central Park, and full-service amenities and meeting spaces.
Bottom line: HI is the practical, social Upper West Side option; Four Seasons is the polished, service-driven Midtown luxury choice. Pick HI for price and community, Four Seasons for location prestige and upscale comforts.
| Category | HI New York City Hostel | Four Seasons Hotel New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Casual, sociable hostel environment with shared common areas and programmed activities | Formal luxury hotel in a Midtown Art Deco–style high-rise |
| Location | Upper West Side (891 Amsterdam Ave), about a 8–10 minute walk to Central Park | Midtown Manhattan (57 E 57th Street), steps from Fifth Avenue and ~0.5 km to Central Park |
| Size | Hostel with multiple dormitory and private room types and large communal spaces | 368 individually decorated guestrooms (supplier listing) |
| Who can stay / ages | All ages welcome; main guest must be 18+ for bookings; family rooms available | |
| Pools | No on-site swimming pool (hostel FAQ / Google listing) | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Big Apple Café (6 AM–11 PM) plus an on-site bar serving beer, wine, non-alcoholic drinks | The Garden Restaurant and a bar/lounge; 24-hour room service available (supplier listing) |
| Spa / wellness | No spa; fitness options limited to exercise mirror and recreational spaces | Not published |
| Known for | Social activities, large outdoor patio/Green Space, budget dorms and event venues | Midtown luxury, individually decorated rooms, concierge and business facilities |
| Event & meeting spaces | Multiple event venues including Ballroom (1,900 sq ft), SoHo Room, Green Space (5,600 sq ft) — used for weddings and conferences | Large conference center and meeting rooms with ~12,120 sq ft (1,126 sq m) of conference space |
| Accessibility & family notes | Wheelchair accessibility noted; family rooms available; children rules for dorms apply | Wheelchair accessible (may have limitations); one child 17 or younger stays free with existing bedding (supplier listing) |
HI New York City Hostel sits on Amsterdam Avenue at West 103rd Street on the Upper West Side, near Central Park.
A calm, residential Upper West Side base with fast subway links to Midtown.
Four Seasons Hotel New York is in Midtown on E 57th Street, near Fifth Avenue and a short walk to Central Park.
Central Midtown address ideal for shopping and sightseeing near major attractions.
HI offers shared dormitory beds and a range of private and family rooms in a landmark Victorian building.
Choose HI for low-cost, shared accommodations and private rooms with communal facilities.
Four Seasons provides 368 individually decorated guestrooms and multiple suite types listed by supplier.
Four Seasons is for travelers who want individually styled rooms and suite choices with premium bedding and in-room comforts.
HI’s food options are focused on an on-site café and a casual hostel bar.
Good for budget meals, self-catering and casual social drinking.
Four Seasons lists The Garden Restaurant and a bar/lounge, plus 24-hour room service.
Four Seasons offers full-service dining and in-room dining options for a higher-end experience.
HI centers its public life on a large outdoor patio/Green Space and communal lounges rather than pool or spa facilities.
The hostel’s outdoor garden and common rooms are the main social and event draw.
Four Seasons emphasizes meeting and business facilities alongside guest services.
A strong choice for business travelers and events who need full-service meeting support.
HI’s on-site recreation focuses on communal activities rather than formal wellness facilities.
Pick HI if you want social nightlife and programmed group activities rather than spa/gym facilities.
Four Seasons lists wellness and business-oriented amenities in the supplier listing.
Four Seasons suits travelers who want full-service support and an on-site fitness option.

Dorms, low-cost private rooms, communal kitchen and free Wi‑Fi make HI the economical pick.

Hosted activities, common lounges, a bar, and large event spaces help groups meet and mingle.

Four Seasons’ location on E 57th Street puts you steps from Fifth Avenue and near major Midtown attractions.

Extensive conference space, a 24-hour business center and full-service concierge support corporate and private events.
Both are close to Central Park, but HI New York City Hostel is on the Upper West Side about an 8–10 minute walk; Four Seasons is roughly 0.5 km from the park on the Midtown side.
HI offers both shared dormitory beds and private/family rooms; some private rooms include en-suite bathrooms.
The supplier listing does not publish pool or spa details for Four Seasons Hotel New York; 'Not published' is recorded for those specifics here.
Yes. HI has several event spaces including the Green Space and Ballroom with published rental terms; Four Seasons lists significant conference and meeting space suitable for events.
Explore how HI New York City Hostel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·