
HI New York City Hostel
Best for social, budget-minded travelers who want a central-UWS base, shared facilities, and on-site event spaces.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
HI New York City Hostel is an informal, budget-friendly hostel in a Victorian-era building on the Upper West Side; this guide is for travelers who want cheap, social accommodation and event space. Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York is an opulent Midtown luxury hotel near MoMA with a full-service spa and pool; this guide is for travelers seeking upscale rooms and a central Midtown location.
Updated · about 4.0 km apart

Best for social, budget-minded travelers who want a central-UWS base, shared facilities, and on-site event spaces.

Best for guests who want luxury Midtown accommodations, a full-service spa, indoor pool and proximity to MoMA and Rockefeller Center.
When HI New York City Hostel wins: pick the hostel if you want the lowest nightly cost, dorm-style social spaces (bar, cafe, games room), a large outdoor patio/garden and flexible event venues for group bookings or budget weddings.
When Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York wins: choose Baccarat if you prefer private, luxury rooms and suites, in-house fine dining (Grand Salon), a full-service spa, indoor pool and a Midtown location within walking distance of MoMA and Rockefeller Center.
Bottom line: both properties work for museum-focused New York trips, but HI New York City Hostel keeps things informal and communal while Baccarat Hotel offers classic Midtown luxury and on-site wellness amenities.
| Category | HI New York City Hostel | Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Informal, communal hostel with shared spaces and daily activities | Formal, luxury hotel with designer details and quiet service |
| Location | Upper West Side (891 Amsterdam Ave), near Central Park and Columbia University | Midtown (28 West 53rd Street), steps from MoMA and Rockefeller Center |
| Size (rooms / capacity) | Dormitory beds plus private and family rooms (multiple dorm configurations listed) | 114 guestrooms, multiple suite types |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome; main booker must be 18; families allowed (children rules apply) | |
| Pools | No swimming pool on site | Indoor pool available |
| Restaurants & bars | Big Apple Café (6:00 AM–11:00 PM) and an on-site bar (closes midnight) | Grand Salon (French cuisine), bar/lounge and room service (limited hours) |
| Spa & wellness | No spa; common-area exercise mirror and games room | Full-service spa with treatments, sauna and fitness center |
| Known for | Historic Victorian building, social activities, large event spaces and garden | Luxury design, proximity to major Midtown museums and attractions |
| Event & meeting space | Multiple event venues (Ballroom, SoHo Room, Green Space, Penthouse) with detailed rental terms | Smaller meeting room(s); concierge and event/ticket assistance |
| Accessibility | Wheelchair accessibility noted; historic building | Wheelchair accessible (may have limitations); elevator |
| Wi‑Fi & tech | Free Wi‑Fi throughout property, common areas and rooms | Free WiFi; tablets and LCD TVs in guestrooms |
HI New York City Hostel sits on Amsterdam Avenue at West 103rd Street, a short walk to Central Park and the 103rd Street (1) subway station.
Best if you want an Uptown, park-adjacent base with cheaper neighborhood options.
Baccarat Hotel is on West 53rd Street, a short walk from the Museum of Modern Art and Rockefeller Center.
Best if you want to be in Midtown within easy walking distance of museums and theaters.
HI New York City Hostel offers multiple dormitory configurations plus private and family rooms, some with en-suite bathrooms.
Choose HI for budget dorms or simple private rooms if social spaces and low rates matter more than private luxury.
Baccarat offers private guestrooms and a range of suites, with in-room tablets, LCD TVs and designer toiletries.
Choose Baccarat for private, full-service rooms and higher-end in-room amenities.
HI New York City Hostel has the Big Apple Café and a small on-site bar, focused on casual, affordable options.
Good for grab-and-go meals, inexpensive coffee and casual evening drinks with other travelers.
Baccarat’s dining centers on the Grand Salon with French cuisine, plus a bar/lounge and room service.
Pick Baccarat for formal dining and in-house luxury service.
HI New York City Hostel focuses on social spaces and event venues rather than wellness facilities.
HI’s strengths are outdoor social space and event hosting—not leisure spa or pool amenities.
Baccarat provides a full-service spa and an indoor pool as part of its luxury amenities.
Baccarat is the choice for on-site wellness, spa treatments and a hotel pool experience.
HI New York City Hostel programs daily social activities and has casual on-site nightlife limited by hostel quiet hours.
Good for younger travelers and groups who want planned social events and a lively common area.
Baccarat emphasizes discreet, upscale service with quieter evening spaces and formal dining.
Baccarat suits travelers who want low-key, luxury evenings and private wellness services.

Dorm beds, shared kitchens, free activities and large event spaces make HI the clear pick for groups on a budget.

Baccarat’s location near MoMA and Rockefeller Center puts you within short walking distance of Midtown attractions.

Baccarat offers a full-service spa and an indoor pool; HI has no spa or pool.

HI provides multiple rentable event spaces including a large Green Space and a historic Ballroom with published rental rates.
Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York is steps from the Museum of Modern Art; HI New York City Hostel is Uptown and requires a subway or taxi ride to reach MoMA.
No — the hostel does not have an on-site pool or spa; it offers common-area recreation like billiards and a movie lounge.
Yes — Baccarat is not adults-only; families can stay, though Baccarat’s service style and fees reflect a luxury property.
Yes — HI has multiple event venues with published capacities and rental rates; Baccarat offers meeting space and concierge assistance but HI lists more and larger event spaces.
Explore how HI New York City Hostel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·