
HI New York City Hostel
Best for meeting other travelers, long-group bookings, and saving on lodging while staying near Central Park.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
HI New York City Hostel is a budget, social hostel in a historic Upper West Side building with dorms, private rooms, and communal facilities — good for solo travelers, groups, and budget-minded families. The Plaza, A Fairmont Hotel is an iconic Fifth Avenue luxury hotel by Central Park — read this if you want to compare a lively hostel base with a classic Central Park luxury stay.
Updated · about 3.5 km apart

Best for meeting other travelers, long-group bookings, and saving on lodging while staying near Central Park.

Best for a formal luxury experience, full-service spa treatments, and a landmark Fifth Avenue address steps from Central Park.
When HI New York City Hostel wins: pick the hostel if you want low-cost beds or private rooms, a strong social program (parties, tours, games room), shared kitchen access, and event spaces for casual or budget-conscious groups.
When The Plaza wins: choose The Plaza if you want individually decorated, full-service rooms with premium bedding, a full-service spa, formal dining and bars, concierge and business facilities, and an iconic Midtown/Central Park address.
Bottom line: these two properties serve different trips. HI NYC is a social, budget-focused base for travelers and groups; The Plaza is a high-end, service-forward landmark hotel for travelers who prioritize luxury, location, and on-site amenities.
| Category | HI New York City Hostel | The Plaza, A Fairmont Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Social, budget, communal | Formal, luxury, landmark |
| Location | Upper West Side — near Central Park and Columbia University | Fifth Avenue at Central Park — steps from Central Park and 5th Avenue shopping |
| Size (rooms) | Hostel with shared dorms and private/family rooms (16 room types) | 282 individually decorated guestrooms |
| Typical ages | Most guests 18–30 but family-friendly and open to all ages | All ages; family-friendly |
| Pools | No pool | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Big Apple Café (6am–11pm) and an on-site bar (closes at midnight) | 2 restaurants, 2 bars/lounges, 24-hour room service |
| Spa & fitness | No spa or gym; games room and exercise mirror in common areas | Full-service spa and 24-hour fitness facilities |
| Event & meeting space | Multiple event spaces including a 1,900 sq ft Ballroom and 5,600 sq ft Green Space | Conference space of 21,496 sq ft and 9 meeting rooms |
| Accessibility | Wheelchair accessibility noted; dorms and historic building layout | Wheelchair accessible (may have limitations); elevator access |
| Known for | Social activities, self-catering kitchen, large outdoor patio/garden | Iconic landmark building, luxury service, Central Park steps away |
HI New York City Hostel sits on Amsterdam Avenue at West 103rd Street on the Upper West Side.
A neighborhood-feel, convenient for Central Park and public transit; farther from Midtown attractions by foot.
The Plaza is on Fifth Avenue at 59th Street, directly beside the southeast corner of Central Park.
A central Midtown location ideal for short walks to Central Park and major Midtown sights.
HI New York City Hostel offers shared dormitory beds plus private and family rooms.
Choose the hostel for budget dorms or basic private rooms when social options and cost matter.
The Plaza provides individually decorated guestrooms and larger deluxe or Grand Luxe options.
Expect full-service, upscale rooms with a range of luxury configurations and accessible options.
HI New York City Hostel provides casual on-site food and a small bar.
Low-cost, flexible dining options focused on self-catering and casual café service.
The Plaza has formal dining venues, bars, and 24-hour room service.
A full-service food and beverage offering suited to formal dining or in-room dining needs.
HI New York City Hostel centres on communal spaces and a large outdoor patio/garden.
The hostel’s appeal is social space and group-friendly public areas rather than private luxury amenities.
The Plaza’s signature is its historic landmark status and formal, high-service public spaces.
Choose The Plaza for landmark status and formal, service-driven public spaces.
HI New York City Hostel focuses on social activities and casual nightlife on-site.
Best for travelers who want social programming and casual in-house nightlife rather than spa treatments.
The Plaza offers wellness services and 24-hour fitness alongside more formal evening options.
If on-site spa treatments and a hotel fitness center are priorities, The Plaza fits those needs.

Dorm beds, shared kitchens, and low-cost private rooms make HI NYC a clear budget pick.

The Plaza offers a landmark Fifth Avenue address, concierge and full-service amenities.

Multiple affordable event spaces (Ballroom, SoHo Room, Green Space) with hourly rates.

The Plaza provides a full-service spa and 24-hour fitness facilities for guests.
The Plaza is steps from Central Park at 59th Street; HI New York City Hostel is about a 8–10 minute walk (≈0.4 mi) to the park from 103rd Street.
Yes. HI NYC offers private and family rooms in addition to dorms; The Plaza offers a range of private, individually decorated guestrooms and accessible rooms.
HI New York City Hostel does not have a pool. The Plaza’s supplier listing does not publish a pool detail.
Both welcome families: HI NYC is family-friendly with specific rules for children in dorms; The Plaza is also family-friendly and allows children to stay (policies and extra charges may apply).
Explore how HI New York City Hostel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·