
HI New York City Hostel
Best for budget travelers, groups and anyone who wants a social, activity-packed Upper West Side base near Central Park.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
HI New York City Hostel is a budget-minded, activity-driven hostel in a Victorian landmark on the Upper West Side; read this if you want cheap, social lodging near Central Park. Mandarin Oriental, New York is a high-end Columbus Circle luxury hotel with spa and skyline/park views; read this if you want full-service comfort, service and location near Central Park South.
Updated · about 2.3 miles (≈3.7 km) apart

Best for budget travelers, groups and anyone who wants a social, activity-packed Upper West Side base near Central Park.

Best for travelers who want luxury rooms, a full-service spa and a central Midtown/Columbus Circle location.
When HI New York City Hostel wins: pick the hostel if your priorities are low cost, meeting other travelers, event/wedding venue options on a budget, or access to a large self-catering kitchen and organized activities.
When Mandarin Oriental, New York wins: choose the Mandarin if you value premium bedding and in-room technology, a full-service spa, an indoor pool, valet and concierge services, and a Columbus Circle address within a short walk of Central Park South and cultural venues.
Bottom line: these two properties serve very different needs. HI is for budget-conscious, social or group travelers who want a practical Upper West Side base; Mandarin Oriental is for guests who want high-end service, wellness and skyline/park views in a central Columbus Circle location.
| Category | HI New York City Hostel | Mandarin Oriental, New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Casual, social, budget-focused hostel life with shared common spaces and programmed activities | Formal, high-end luxury hotel with full-service amenities and concierge |
| Location | Upper West Side, near Central Park (about 0.4 mi to Central Park); close to 103rd St subway | Columbus Circle / Time Warner Center, steps from Central Park South and Lincoln Center |
| Size (rooms/guests) | Not published | 244 guestrooms |
| Room types | Shared dormitory beds (male/female/mixed) and private/family rooms; dorms from 4–14 beds | Many configurations including Hudson View Twin, Central Park View King, Premier Central Park View King, Hudson River Suite, Suite Standard, Family Room, Connecting Rooms |
| Pools | No swimming pool on site | Indoor pool (listed among amenities) |
| Restaurants & bars | Big Apple Café (6:00 AM–11:00 PM) and an on-site bar (closes midnight) | MO Lounge / 24-hour room service and two bars/lounges (hotel listing) |
| Spa & wellness | No spa; common-area exercise mirror and yoga activities | Full-service spa with massages, body treatments and facials; health club and sauna |
| Event spaces | Multiple on-site venues (Ballroom, SoHo Room, Green Space, Penthouse) with capacities up to ~150–163 and outdoor garden space | Meeting/ballroom space (number of meeting rooms listed as 1) and banquet/ballroom facilities |
| Family friendliness / ages | All ages welcome; main guest must be 18+; children allowed with rules for bunks | Not adults-only; children policies not published in supplied listing |
| Distance between properties | — | |
HI New York City Hostel sits on Amsterdam Avenue at West 103rd Street, a short walk from Central Park and local subway lines.
Pick HI if you want a budget base on the Upper West Side with easy subway access; it’s farther uptown from Midtown attractions.
Mandarin Oriental, New York sits at 80 Columbus Circle at 60th Street, adjacent to Central Park South and within walking distance of Midtown attractions.
Pick Mandarin Oriental for a central Midtown/Columbus Circle location with easy walking access to major cultural sites.
HI offers shared dormitory beds and private/family rooms in a historic Victorian building.
Choose HI for inexpensive shared accommodation or simple private rooms in a landmark building.
Mandarin Oriental provides a wide mix of premium rooms and suites with river or park views and upscale in-room amenities.
Choose Mandarin Oriental for spacious, service-oriented rooms with premium fixtures and skyline/park or river views.
HI keeps dining simple with the Big Apple Café and an on-site bar.
HI is best for low-cost, self-catered meals and a casual on-site café and bar.
Mandarin Oriental offers full-service dining options including a lounge, bars and 24-hour room service.
Mandarin Oriental suits travelers who prefer in-house fine dining, lounges and full room service.
HI focuses on communal spaces rather than a spa or pool.
HI’s strengths are social common areas and an outdoor Green Space, not pool or spa facilities.
Mandarin Oriental highlights a full-service spa, health club and an indoor pool as part of its luxury offering.
Mandarin Oriental is the pick for guests who prioritize a hotel spa, pool and structured wellness services.
HI programs free activities and maintains a lively, social evening atmosphere within hostel quiet hours.
HI is for social travelers who want programmed activities and communal nightlife on a budget.
Mandarin Oriental emphasizes private, service-led experiences with concierge-arranged activities and quiet luxury.
Mandarin Oriental serves guests seeking private wellness services and concierge-planned activities rather than hostel-style nightlife.

HI New York City Hostel — low-cost dorms and private rooms, a self-catering kitchen and free activities.

HI New York City Hostel — communal spaces, free events and a bar that makes meeting other travelers easy.

Mandarin Oriental, New York — full-service spa, indoor pool, sauna and fitness classes on site.

Mandarin Oriental, New York — immediate access to Columbus Circle, Central Park South and Midtown attractions.
Both are close to Central Park, but HI New York City Hostel is about 0.4 miles to the park from its Upper West Side address; Mandarin Oriental sits at Columbus Circle on Central Park South.
No — the hostel does not have a swimming pool; the property’s communal amenities focus on a garden, games room and common areas.
The supplied listing does not indicate an adults-only policy; children are allowed and the hotel lists family and connecting room options, though specific child policies are not published in the supplied facts.
HI New York City Hostel has multiple event spaces including a large Green Space and Ballroom with published capacity and hourly rates; Mandarin Oriental provides banquet/meeting facilities but HI’s on-site venue options are explicitly detailed for larger casual events.
Explore how HI New York City Hostel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·