
HI New York City Hostel
Best for budget travelers, groups, and social travelers who prioritize events, shared kitchens, and an Upper West Side base.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
HI New York City Hostel is an affordable, all-ages hostel in a historic Upper West Side building that offers shared dorms, private rooms, and regular social events. The St. Regis New York is a historic Fifth Avenue five-star luxury hotel known for classic grand rooms, extensive suite options, and butler service; read this if you’re deciding between budget/social stays and high-end Midtown luxury.
Updated · about 3.8 km apart

Best for budget travelers, groups, and social travelers who prioritize events, shared kitchens, and an Upper West Side base.

Best for travelers seeking historic Fifth Avenue luxury, butler service, and a central Midtown location near Rockefeller Center and 5th Avenue shopping.
When HI New York City Hostel wins: Choose HI if you want the lowest cost per night, shared common areas to meet other travelers, free activities (welcome parties, walking tours), a self-catering kitchen, or large low-cost event spaces. Families and groups on a budget will also appreciate the variety of dorm and private room options.
When The St. Regis New York wins: Choose The St. Regis if you want a full-service luxury experience in Midtown — larger private rooms and many one-bedroom suites with butler service, concierge, valet, meeting and event facilities, on-site restaurants, and a central location steps from 5th Avenue and Rockefeller Center.
Bottom line: Pick HI New York City Hostel for price-conscious, social, and group travel with easy access to Central Park from the Upper West Side. Pick The St. Regis New York for classic, full-service luxury and convenience in Midtown Manhattan — the two properties serve very different trip goals.
| Category | HI New York City Hostel | The St. Regis New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Budget, social hostel life with shared spaces and daily activities | Formal, historic grand-luxury hotel with full-service amenities |
| Location | Upper West Side near Central Park, close to 103rd St subway | Midtown Manhattan on Fifth Avenue, steps from Rockefeller Center |
| Size | Single landmark building with dorms and some private rooms (16 room types listed) | 238 guestrooms (mix of rooms and many suites listed) |
| Who can stay / ages | All ages; main guest must be 18+; families welcome with rules for children in dorms | All ages allowed (not adults-only) |
| Pools | No swimming pool | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Big Apple Café (6:00 AM–11:00 PM) and an on-site bar (closes at midnight) | Two restaurants, one bar/lounge, and in-room service (limited hours) |
| Spa / wellness | No spa; exercise mirror and common-area fitness-style options | Not published |
| Known for | Affordable shared accommodations, self-catering kitchen, social events and large event spaces (Ballroom, Green Space) | Historic Fifth Avenue grand luxury, butler service, central Midtown location |
| Event & meeting spaces | Multiple rentable spaces including a 1,900 sq ft Ballroom, 5,600 sq ft Green Space, SoHo Room, Penthouse | Conference space ~3,944 sq ft with 13 meeting rooms and ballrooms |
| Accessibility & family rules | Wheelchair accessibility in parts of the property; specific child-in-dorm rules and residency restriction for NYC locals | Wheelchair-accessible features listed (paths, registration desk, meeting spaces) |
HI New York City Hostel sits on Amsterdam Avenue at West 103rd Street, a short walk to Central Park and local subway lines.
Great if you want a more residential, park-adjacent base and easy subway access to Midtown.
The St. Regis New York is on Two East 55th Street, directly on Fifth Avenue in Midtown Manhattan.
Choose The St. Regis for immediate access to Midtown landmarks and Fifth Avenue shopping.
HI New York City Hostel offers shared dorm beds in gendered and mixed rooms plus private and family rooms.
Best for travelers willing to share rooms to save money or travel in groups/families on a budget.
The St. Regis New York lists a wide range of luxury rooms and many one-bedroom suites, most with butler service.
Expect spacious, full-service private rooms and suites geared to luxury travelers and business guests.
HI New York City Hostel keeps dining simple with the Big Apple Café and an on-site bar.
Good for low-cost, flexible meals and meeting other guests in shared dining spaces.
The St. Regis New York offers full-service dining with two restaurants, a bar/lounge, and limited-hours room service.
Choose The St. Regis for formal dining options and full-service meal and concierge support.
HI New York City Hostel emphasizes social common areas, including a large outdoor patio/garden.
The Green Space and patio are the hostel’s primary outdoor/amenity draw — social, low-cost, and event-friendly.
The St. Regis New York lists a broad set of full-service hotel amenities and dedicated meeting space.
St. Regis focuses on full-service hotel amenities and meeting/event infrastructure in Midtown.
HI New York City Hostel centers wellness and nightlife on low-cost, social activities and communal spaces.
HI’s on-site activities and communal rooms are aimed at sociable travelers rather than formal wellness services.
The St. Regis New York provides classic hotel services and quick access to Midtown nightlife and theaters.
St. Regis supports a full-service leisure and events program plus easy access to Midtown entertainment.

HI New York City Hostel — cheap dorm beds, free social events, and a big common kitchen make it easy to save and meet people.

The St. Regis New York — extensive suite inventory and butler service suit travelers wanting full-service, private luxury.

HI New York City Hostel — multiple rentable event spaces (Ballroom, Green Space) at rates geared to budget events.

The St. Regis New York — immediate access to 5th Avenue, Rockefeller Center and Midtown business and tourist sites.
HI New York City Hostel — it’s about an 8–10 minute walk to Central Park from the Upper West Side address.
Yes — many rooms and suites listed for The St. Regis New York specifically include 'Butler Service Included.'
HI New York City Hostel does not have a swimming pool or spa. The St. Regis listing supplied does not publish on-site pool or spa details.
Yes — families can stay at HI New York City Hostel, but the main guest must be 18+, children over 2 need their own bunk in dorms, and under-7s cannot use top bunks.
Both have event capabilities: HI New York City Hostel offers several low-cost event spaces including a large outdoor Green Space; The St. Regis provides formal meeting and ballroom space in Midtown (about 3,944 sq ft and 13 meeting rooms).
Explore how HI New York City Hostel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·