
HI New York City Hostel
Best for budget travelers, groups, and guests who want a social, self-catered stay near Central Park.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
HI New York City Hostel is a budget, social hostel in a historic Upper West Side building with dorms, private rooms, a large self-catering kitchen and group event spaces — read this if you want low-cost, social or group-friendly lodging near Central Park. The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel is a storied Upper East Side five-star hotel known for old-New York glamour, fine dining and a full-service spa — read this if you want classic luxury close to the Met and Central Park.
Updated · about 2.2 km apart

Best for budget travelers, groups, and guests who want a social, self-catered stay near Central Park.

Best for travelers seeking landmark Upper East Side luxury, a full-service spa and formal dining in a classic Manhattan hotel.
When HI New York City Hostel wins: choose the hostel if you’re traveling on a tight budget, want to meet other travelers, need shared kitchen facilities or are booking large groups or event space on a limited budget. The hostel’s activities, big garden and multiple rentable venues make it a practical, social base for exploring the city.
When The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel wins: pick The Carlyle if you want refined service, a quiet luxury setting near the Metropolitan Museum of Art and Central Park, a full-service spa and on-site fine dining/Bemelman's Bar. It’s aimed at travelers who value history, polished rooms and concierge-driven convenience.
Bottom line: these two properties serve very different needs in uptown Manhattan — HI New York City Hostel is a low-cost, social and group-oriented option on the Upper West Side; The Carlyle is a five-star Upper East Side hotel for travelers after classic luxury and full-service amenities. Your choice should come down to budget, desired level of service and whether you prefer a communal hostel vibe or formal hotel comfort.
| Category | HI New York City Hostel | The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Budget, social, communal spaces and daily activities | Formal, classic Upper East Side luxury with polished service |
| Location | Upper West Side near Central Park (about an 8–10 minute walk) | Upper East Side near Madison Ave; within a 10-minute walk of Central Park and the Met |
| Size | Historic hostel with dorms, private and family rooms (16 room types listed) | 188 guestrooms (room types listed in supplier data) |
| Rooms — typical offerings | Shared dorm beds (mixed and single-gender) plus private and family rooms; some en-suite options | Multiple categories from Superior King to many suite types (Superior Suite, Rosewood/Carlyle/Central Park variants) |
| Pools | No pool | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Big Apple Café (snacks/coffee 6am–11pm) and an on-site bar (closes at midnight) | Two restaurants, a coffee shop/café and Bemelman's Bar; 24-hour room service available |
| Spa / wellness | No full spa; shared common-area fitness-style mirror and games rooms | Full-service spa and health club listed |
| Event & meeting spaces | Multiple rentable spaces (Ballroom, SoHo Room, Green Space, Penthouse) with capacities up to ~150–163 and known rental terms | Number of meeting rooms - 1; formal meeting/event support and concierge services |
| Known for | Social atmosphere, self-catering kitchen, large outdoor garden and budget group events | Old-New-York glamour, location near Central Park/Met, Bemelman's Bar and refined service |
| Accessibility & family policies | Family-friendly; main guest must be 18+ and minors must be accompanied; no pets; service animals allowed | Not adults-only; wheelchair features listed but may have limitations; valet and other full-service hotel policies |
HI New York City Hostel sits at 891 Amsterdam Avenue near West 103rd Street on the Upper West Side, a short walk to Central Park and local subway lines.
Choose HI for a lively Upper West Side base with easy park access and cheaper transit-oriented location.
The Carlyle is at 35 E 76th St on the Upper East Side, minutes from Madison Avenue, Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art.
Choose The Carlyle for a central, uptown location that’s convenient for museums and formal sightseeing.
HI New York City Hostel offers dormitory beds and private/family rooms in a Victorian-era building, with 16 room-type listings.
If you want very low rates and social dorms or family rooms, HI’s variety of shared and private options work better.
The Carlyle’s 188 guestrooms range from Superior King rooms to multiple named suites, aimed at luxury travelers.
Pick The Carlyle when you want private, full-service rooms and an array of suite categories.
HI New York City Hostel relies on its Big Apple Café and an on-site bar for casual dining and drinks.
HI is best for low-cost, self-catered meals and casual social dining.
The Carlyle lists two restaurants, a coffee shop and the well-known Bemelman's Bar, plus 24-hour room service.
The Carlyle suits travelers who want formal dining options and classic hotel bar service.
HI New York City Hostel’s notable extras are its large event spaces, regular free activities and a big outdoor Green Space.
HI stands out for budget-friendly event rentals and social programming for groups and travelers.
The Carlyle’s standout features are its full-service spa, concierge services and a classic hotel bar experience.
The Carlyle is aimed at travelers who value spa treatments, concierge service and traditional hotel amenities.
HI New York City Hostel offers communal recreation, evening activities and a small, social bar that closes at midnight.
For social nightlife and on-site group activities, HI provides more casual, communal options.
The Carlyle provides a health club, full-service spa and a quieter, more formal nightlife option via Bemelman's Bar and hotel dining.
Choose The Carlyle for formal wellness services and a quieter, refined evening atmosphere.

HI New York City Hostel — lowest rates, dorms, self-catering kitchen and social spaces.

The Carlyle — five-star rooms, full-service spa, fine dining and concierge support.

HI New York City Hostel — multiple rentable venues (Green Space, Ballroom, SoHo Room, Penthouse) and group-friendly policies.

The Carlyle — steps from Madison Ave, within a 10-minute walk of Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art.
Both are close to Central Park; HI New York City Hostel is about an 8–10 minute walk, while The Carlyle is within a roughly 10-minute walk from the park and the Met.
HI New York City Hostel does not allow pets (service animals allowed). The Carlyle’s supplier listing notes a pet fee and indicates pets are allowed with a surcharge; service animals are exempt from fees at The Carlyle per its listing.
HI New York City Hostel — communal dorms, daily activities, a games room and common kitchen make it easier to meet other travelers.
HI New York City Hostel does not have a swimming pool. The Carlyle’s supplier listing does not publish pool information.
Explore how HI New York City Hostel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·